高级检索

    基于分位数回归法的杉木可变指数削度方程构建

    Modeling variable exponential taper function for Cunninghamia lanceolata based on quantile regression

    • 摘要:
        目的  采用非线性分位数回归法构建不同分位点的杉木可变指数削度方程,与非线性模型进行比较,以提高杉木干形的预测精度。
        方法  利用福建省将乐国有林场的73 株(793组)杉木解析木数据,选取4个可变指数削度方程,基于5折交叉验证,分别采用非线性分位数回归与非线性回归构建削度方程。选用调整后决定系数(R2)、均方根误差(RMSE)、平均误差(ME)、相对误差(RE)和平均绝对误差(MAE)5个模型评价指标,结合图形对各模型的拟合结果和预测结果进行评价。
        结果  (1)4个可变指数削度方程在5个分位点(t = 0.1, 0.3, 0.5, 0.7, 0.9)处均能收敛,说明分位数回归可以建立不同分位点的估测模型,能更全面地描述杉木干形的变化。(2)4个削度方程在分位点为0.5处的精度最高,R2均在0.97左右。对于削度方程M1和M3,基于中位数回归(t = 0.5)的拟合精度与预测精度均高于非线性回归,且M1的预测值更加集中。(3)在不同分位点下,各模型对树干不同位置的预测精度不同,分位值为0.9和0.3的模型分别对梢头部分和树干基部的预测精度最高。
        结论  基于分位数回归的可变指数削度方程不仅能精确预测平均条件下杉木的树干直径,而且能预测任意分位条件下杉木干形的变化趋势。不同分位点模型对树干不同位置的预测精度不同,基于M1削度方程,建立多分位点回归模型能进一步提高研究区杉木干形的预测精度。

       

      Abstract:
        Objective  In order to improve prediction accuracy of Chinese fir stem profile, we used nonlinear quantile regression to establish variable exponential taper equations at different quantile points, and compared their fitting and prediction accuracy with nonlinear regression model.
        Method  This study took 73 Chinese fir (Cunninghamia lanceolata) stem data from the Jiangle Forest Farm in Fujian Province of eastern China. Then we selected 4 variable exponential taper equations, and based on 5-fold cross-validation, used nonlinear quantile regression and nonlinear regression to establish taper equations, respectively. Five model evaluation indicators were selected, including the adjusted coefficient of determination (R2), root mean square error (RMSE), average error (ME), relative error (RE) and average absolute error (MAE), combined with graphs to evaluate the fitting and prediction results.
        Result  The research results showed: (1) the 4 variable exponential taper equations converged at all quantile points (t = 0.1, 0.3, 0.5, 0.7, 0.9), indicating that quantile regression can develop different models at different quantiles. So this method can describe the change of Chinese fir stem shape more comprehensively. (2) The accuracy of four taper equations at the quantile point of 0.5 was all higher than others, with R2 about 0.97. For taper equations M1 and M3, the fitting and prediction accuracy based on the median regression (t = 0.5) were both higher than those of nonlinear regression. And the prediction values of the M1 equation were more concentrated. (3) At different quantile points, models had different prediction accuracies for varied stem positions. Models with quantile values of 0.9 and 0.3 had the highest prediction accuracy for the stem top part and the base part, respectively.
        Conclusion  The variable exponential taper equations developed by quantile regression can not only accurately predict stem diameters under average condition, but also predict the changing trend of stem shape under arbitrary quantile conditions. Quantile models have different prediction accuracies for varied stem positions. The multi-quantile regression model of M1 can further improve the prediction accuracy of the Chinese fir stem profile.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回