高级检索

    基于地表枯落物的植物群落抗火性评价以上海市环城绿带为例

    Evaluation of fire resistance of plant communities based on ground litter: a case study of the green belt around Shanghai City, eastern China

    • 摘要:
      目的 火灾是城市人居环境的主要灾害之一,严重威胁居民的生命财产安全及城市的生态效益。本文构建了基于地表枯落物的植物群落抗火性综合评价体系,旨在为城市绿地系统的火灾防控与管理、生态安全保障以及绿地健康维护提供新的思路与解决方案。
      方法 本研究以上海市环城绿带典型乔木群落和地表枯落物为研究对象,通过实地调研获取质量特征与空间分布数据,其中单位面积质量平均值、变异系数、偏度和峰度4个指标来描述地表枯落物的质量特征;选择变程和分维数,通过Kriging插值法分析其空间分布。并且使用量热仪得到热值、燃烧时间、温度变化和不完全燃烧指数等实测数据,用以表征群落的燃烧特性。基于上述3个方面共10个指标,采用CRITIC权重法构建地表枯落物的群落抗火性综合评价体系,并对群落抗火性进行排序和分析。
      结果 (1)不同群落的地表枯落物单位面积质量差异显著,范围为46.92 ~ 604.48 g/m2;桂花B群落的离散程度最高,变异系数、偏度和峰度均最大。(2)地表枯落物的空间分布呈现3类抗火性排序:破碎化分布(第1类) > 局部集中式分布(第2类) > 大面积集中式分布(第3类)。(3)池杉群落和落羽杉群落的地表枯落物热值较高、不完全燃烧指数较低、燃烧时间长、温度变化中等,抗火性较差;相同条件下,朴树群落的地表枯落物较难引燃;总体而言,针叶树群落抗火能力弱于阔叶树群落。(4)基于综合评价体系,21个群落的抗火性排序从强到弱为朴树B群落、桂花B群落、(梧桐 + 女贞)群落 、无患子B群落 、(栾树 + 女贞)群落、无患子A群落、 香樟群落、(枫香 + 枫杨)群落 、 (杜英 + 鹅掌楸)群落 、朴树A群落、银杏群落、 (银杏 + 香樟 + 女贞)群落、 (蚊母树 + 杨树)群落、 栾树群落、(女贞 + 无患子)群落、榉树群落、池杉群落、三角槭群落、桂花A群落、女贞群落、落羽杉群落。
      结论 地表枯落物数量越少、分布破碎化程度越高、燃烧性越弱的群落,其综合抗火能力越强。

       

      Abstract:
      Objective Fire is one of the major disasters affecting urban human settlement environment, which brings increasingly severe challenges to residents’ personal property and urban ecological benefits. In this paper, a comprehensive evaluation system of fire resistance of plant communities based on ground litter was constructed, which provides a new control idea for fire prevention and control and management of urban green space system, urban ecological safety and maintenance of green space health.
      Method In this study, typical arbor communities and surface litter in the Shanghai Ring Green Belt were taken as research objects. Field survey was carried out to obtain data on mass characteristics and spatial distribution. Four indices, namely the average mass per unit area, coefficient of variation, skewness and kurtosis were used to describe mass characteristics of surface litter. Its spatial distribution was analyzed through range, fractal dimension, and Kriging interpolation. In addition, a calorimeter was used to obtain measured data such as calorific value, combustion time, temperature change, and incomplete combustion index, which were used to characterize the combustion characteristics of communities. Based on a total of 10 indices from the above three aspects, the CRITIC (criteria importance through intercriteria correlation) weight method was adopted to construct a comprehensive evaluation system for fire resistance of surface litter communities, and fire resistance of communities was ranked and analyzed.
      Result (1) The average mass per unit area of ground litter in different communities varied greatly, ranging from 46.92 to 604.48 g/m2. The mass dispersion degree of ground litter per unit area of each community was large, that is, there were a lot of fallen leaves deposited in some areas, and the mass was far above average value. The highest degree of dispersion was Osmanthus fragrans B community, and its coefficient of variation, skewness and kurtosis were the largest. (2) In terms of spatial distribution of ground litter, the comparative order of fire resistance was as follows: type I (fragmentation distribution) > type II (local centralized distribution) > type III (large area centralized distribution). (3) The heat value of ground litter was high, incomplete combustion index was small, burning time was long, temperature was moderate, and fire resistance was poor. Under same conditions, the ground litter of community was difficult to ignite. In general, fire resistance of conifer community was lower than that of broadleaved trees. (4) According to comprehensive evaluation system, the order of fire resistance of 21 communities from strong to weak was as follows: Celtis sinensis B community, Osmanthus fragrans B community, Firmiana simplex + Ligustrum lucidum community, Sapindus saponaria B community, Koelreuteria paniculata + Ligustrum lucidum community, Sapindus saponaria A community, Camphora septentrionalis community, Liquidambar formosana + Pterocarya stenoptera community, Elaeocarpus decipiens + Liriodendron chinense community, Celtis sinensis A community > Ginkgo biloba community, Ginkgo biloba + Camphora officinarum + Ligustrum lucidum community, Distylium racemosum + Populus euramericana ‘I-214’ community, Koelreuteria paniculata community, Ligustrum lucidum + Sapindus saponaria community, Zelkova serrata community, Taxodium distichum var. imbricatum community, Acer buergerianum community, Osmanthus fragrans A community, Ligustrum lucidum community, Taxodium distichum community.
      Conclusion Communities with less surface litter, more fragmented distribution and weaker combustibility have stronger overall fire resistance.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回